ADR 0010: The look — opaque clay on a painted ground, colours within one palette, detail drawn softly
- Status: accepted
- Date: 2026-06, rewritten 2026-10; the glass veto lifted 2026-11
Context
The default picture is the product: a pastel, archviz city of clay on paper. Earlier building styles (raw LoD colours, transmissive "ghost" glass) doubled every shader or rendered the scene twice. A procedural window grid read as an office block over historic silhouettes; raw OSM colours put a signal-red facade into a pastel city. Detail has to come from data, read the same on every house, and stay calm.
Decision
- One building material: opaque clay with a per-building tint and the
facade terms of the clay shader. No
transmission, no textures, no second building style. Other looks are picture styles over the frame (ADR 0034). - Colour comes from data and stays in the palette. Roofs from the orthophoto under each roof, lifted by a hue-preserving vibrance; walls from OSM colour, else material family, else use. A mapped colour keeps its hue with capped saturation and held lightness. Glass and metal are object flags with a subtle response, not a texture.
- The ground is painted at runtime from one palette
(
lib/city/landcover.ts): the bake writes class ids only, so a colour change is a code change, not a re-bake. - Windows are drawn by the clay's fragment shader on every house — a recess with a sill, its back a muted pane that mirrors a little sky at a grazing view. Their rhythm per building is measured where open street photos saw it (Panoramax, Mapillary — never Google Street View), else a neighbour's, else its type's. None on party walls, over doors or a measured shopfront; a monumental facade gets no town-house windows (listed palaces a kind of their own, churches none). No window row below the ground in front of the wall. Within 250 m the openings are cut and real niches stand behind them, laid on the shader's own grid, so drawn and real windows are one window; a house turns as a whole, never a wall in part.
- Facade parts are soft, abstract geometry: plinths, cornices, doors from OSM entrances, dormers, shop fascias — rounded profiles, never hard bevels, relief lit from above and never darker than the wall. Landmarks get none of the generic parts.
- Glass where it helps the facade read: a shop window is an opening cut into its wall, reveals in the wall's clay and glass at its back, as a window is a recess (a real one at every distance, as wide as the measured bay). Panes and glass walls mirror the street's skyline and the sky above it, read from the baked horizon — a stand-in house below the skyline, never a second render of the scene. A glass wall shows its frame — mullions and a transom a storey — the one grid on a facade.
- Night: walls do not glow; every unlit or additive layer is dimmed by the one night factor.
- Water is matte (a sun path, glints, gentle waves); fountains keep their sky mirror. After dark the river mirrors the lamps by the water, as points of light on the waves, never the scene.
Consequences
- One shader budget, spent on post and shadows, not on a second scene.
- A new building attribute is a row in the object table that tints within the palette, never a texture.
- A new facade term must fit the clay's varyings (ADR 0027) and read the flat facet normal.
Alternatives
- Ghost (transmission) or raw LoD styles: a style that halves the frame rate is a trap.
- A uniform window grid or a window texture over every facade: read as an office block over historic silhouettes.
- No glass at all (until 2026-11): windows seen obliquely read as flat paint; a pane's grazing sky is what tells their depth.
- Geometry niches baked into the mesh: plump at the mesh's precision and only on measured walls; a street with every thirtieth house windowed was rejected. Niches at runtime on the shader's grid (2026-11) have neither fault.
- Niches cut on every tile: a discard costs the clay its early depth test, so only the tiles near the eye build it.
- Blending roofs toward terracotta: destroyed the real copper greens.
- Raw OSM colours: pure hues in a pastel city.
- A palette lookup per fragment: class ids cannot be mipmapped.
